Quote
Originally posted by John Kotches:
You can't use MRC this way though. You either run MRC first or you run MRC last. You can't run MRC multiple times and apply multiple passes. The 2nd run wipes out the results of the first run.
I know MRC is wiped between runs.

I also think that I get the best results by first applying DD-EQ and then MRC. But it's not as easy as that.

Velodyne assumes that their DD-EQ is the only EQ to be used, but before you run it you should do whatever you can to help it. This includes placement of speakers, volume level calibration, acoustic treatment of the room... Then DD-EQ puts in the "Final Touches". If you after running DD-EQ rearrange furniture, change material in walls, replace front speakers a.s.o. you won't get any (positive) effect from DD-EQ.

Both DD-EQ and MRC are "Poor Man's Acoustic Treatment", though with the "twist" being more expensive than "real" acoustic treatment of the room. "Poor man" is here referring to "a man not allowed by his wife to destroy the looks of the living room". So, for both it's "wrong" not to run them last - it will equal running either while the construction workers are still putting the finishing touches to the room.

It didn't take much testing for me to se that it was better for me to run DD-EQ first and then MRC. This seems to be the common point of view, though I'm not sure if it applies to every room/equipment combination. But DD-EQ will then anyway have to work with "that untreated room"...

So I tested "rough MRC" (without DD-12) --> DD-EQ --> MRC. This will "mimic" the following scenario:
* "Rough MRC": Speakers are placed where they sound the best, furniture/carpets are moved to get a good listening position, wall treatment & curtains shorten the reverberation time somewhat, level calibration of speakers is done.
* DD-EQ: The DD-12 is integrated into the system and by "adding bass where the rest of the system gives too little" the response for low frequencies is clearly a bit more correct.
* MRC: The speakers are once again placed where thay sound best, carpets/walls/furniture are taken care of... Being the same people doing the same work, the result will of course be similar to before. They have the DD-12 to take into account, and they are being given more time to optimize evrything. The end result is pretty decent.

This is the theory, and testing has shown that I get a slightly better end result this way. But the problem is that it's mostly for test signals/situations... frown This is because the D1500, while playing "real music", usually doesn't get sent to it the bass information it could use to improve the bass response in the room. That is why I want both subs to play the same (source) bass, otherwise they can't really complement each other.

Quote
Originally posted by John Kotches:
Well, there is the fact that you have two physically different subwoofers which is a less than ideal circumstance.

They have different performance characteristics and assigning them identical content probably goes against sound acoustic practices if you'll pardon the pun.
OK, for this time... wink

That would indeed be acoustically unsound if the two subs where to be sent exactly the same sound information to be played after it was processed by DD-EQ and MRC. That's of course not what I want. They should be sent the same source material - level settings, DD-EQ and MRC will take care of the subs being different. Radio Shack will see to that volumes match even though the DD-12 is more powerful, DD-EQ will affect the DD-12 but not the D1500 - that's sound (if you pardon the pun...)

You would of course need to calibrate the system with both subs playing concurrently, otherwise you would get too much bass. Either you do that manually or get an extra function for it in the processor. With "manually" I mean that you (I) first calibrate each sub independently (with the other turned off, since both subs should simultaneously get the same source) so their volume levels match. You then use the old trusty RS again while both are playing, lowering the volume equally much on both subs to match the rest of the system.


HD621, G98DH, G68ADV, Bc Acoustiqe ACT A3, 5200C DSP33, NuForce Reference 9 monoblocks, 2x SB3's, Velodyne DD-15 & DD-12 Subwoofers and a Meridian sub.