I'd just like to make a point about relativity, most of the folks on this forum are lifelong hifi/music aficionados, knowledge cultivated over years which in itself brings a degree of confidence to challenge the perceptions of commentators etc.
I got into hifi in the mid to late eighties as a direct result of purchasing a copy of What HiFi to try and make some sense out of the options available to me. Ended up buying my first system as a collection of at the time best buys - Rega Turntable (incidentally still have the same one), Arcam Alpha 3 Amplifier and Cyrus 780 speakers. When i went to a local hifi shop to audition and ultimately buy, they attempted to throw a few alternate options in my direction - Creek speakers were one if memory serves. Anyway i didn't have a clue what i was hearing despite the advice and went with the What HiFi recommendations.
Did i buy the best at the time for the money, undoubtedly not. Was i happy with my purchase - without question. It started a lifelong journey which diverged from the What HiFi publication and opinion as i picked up my own knowledge and sought alternate views.
Is there a place for a publication like that therefore - yes, it wont convert the faithful but plays a role in the mass market which may only need a steer toward a bunch of options every now and again. When i recently purchased my HD700 headphones I did look at their best buy guides but only as one of 20+ sources.
I'm not sure we should at all take any offence at their views, they are just that - views. Those that know.......know..

lee