logo

Google Search  |  Meridian Systems  |  Meridian Streaming  |  Restaurant  |  WiKi  |  Duncan's Meridian Info  |  Board Rules  |  Restaurant Rules
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Rate Thread
Page 3 of 4 1 2 3 4
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 4,014
Vogon Civil Servant
Vogon Civil Servant
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 4,014
You wish to have "True Scientific Neutrality" and yet it is patently obvious that your own tests have none of that, as you know exactly which Rips are which?

You ask for a "Compensation Algorithm", and yet you deem that your own test don't require any such algorithm to compensate for the very obvious "expectation bias" that you yourself had in performing such a test... ("for those who want the best" is a very telling bias IMHO).

So, if you don't trust others to carry out an objective test, what about sending 2-3 of your Files to a Moderator here who would then relabel and De-Metadata them and then return them to you.

With these "blind" files, you can then listen at length to attempt to identify which File is which (i.e. Ripped by dBpa or CPC / EAC).

As you don't seem to trust the Ears or Objectivity of the others on this Forum, would you be willing to "scientifically" test your own Ears and Objectivity?


-
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 8,816
Likes: 87
President of the Imperial Galactic Government
President of the Imperial Galactic Government
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 8,816
Likes: 87
Indeed... I am a bit puzzled. There is an obvious temptation to ridicule any findings concerning the possible differences in ripping. It's all 1's and 0's etc.

So, I suggest we all have a listen to some tracks that are ripped via EAC, dBpa and laptop with battery etc.

Put them up and see if anyone can rate them. Get an independent to host the files and you can join in too. No one can have any expectation if they don't know what the files are.

If you are worried that some folks will hear nothing because they expect to hear nothing then we can throw some diff tracks in... e.g a FLAC made from a 128 MP3 track. Should be obvious but if you don't know which one it is then you'd better listen.

I don't believe I have seen this done on the web before.

I am happy to host if it helps.


Rgds,
Nick


Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 7,950
Likes: 19
Ian Offline
President of the Imperial Galactic Government
President of the Imperial Galactic Government
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 7,950
Likes: 19
There are a number of upcoming events, SSAV Bristol, Meridian West London etc.

I wonder if any would consider dedicating a room over to blind testing? Testing different sources, cables and storage.

I am sure that there would be enough like minded people through the doors to make a valid sample size.


Meridian owner since 1992
Prime & PSU, Focal Elear headphones, Roon (ROCK 8Gi5 NUC), Explorer 1 & 2, F80. 200/203, various Sonos (via Roon).
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 12,733
Likes: 88
Don't Panic!
Don't Panic!
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 12,733
Likes: 88
Originally Posted by Shere Khan
I can't be bothered with that, I have no time for that nonsense.
wink


Roon Developer and ex-moderator of this Forum
I am #25 in the HH1 photo of fame.
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 1,870
Likes: 13
MI' Offline
Knows where his towel is
Knows where his towel is
Offline
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 1,870
Likes: 13
Excellent VK!


Under review
Joined: Apr 2012
Posts: 3,177
Likes: 171
Hooloovoo
Hooloovoo
Joined: Apr 2012
Posts: 3,177
Likes: 171
Sorry guys, for some reason when this got branched off from the other thread I thought I'd subscribed but never did, so I missed this fascinating discussion! It's genuinely nice to see at least the possibility of difference being rationally and civilly debated (I've been on forums where the mere mention of a cable would result in all-out war).

Nick, you asked a while back whether my initial impression of this was based on a comparison of the same track - it was, and there's a thread a while back when I queried the difference at the time, with someone kindly checking the checksums, which they concluded were identical. The odd thing is that I wasn't consciously comparing the two tracks for differences to start with, it was more accidental that I heard a difference, which I then explored consciously.

In any case, I'd have to do a longer term, randomised test (perhaps along the lines you suggest) to really work out whether it was objective or whether, for whatever reason the first time I heard a difference I was in a bad mood, tired, tilting my head a fraction, or sitting in a slightly different position to normal, etc., etc. At the time, past the initial day or so of comparisons, I didn't have too much time, so just went back to using Control:Mac.

I'm up for the kind of blind testing on the forum you're suggesting though, might be really interesting. I do understand the earlier objection, though - I think what was being suggested is that expectation bias is also true for those who expect no difference (if you truly believe there can be no difference, will you be open to hearing it whether it's there or not?). The suggestion of lower bitrate samples, compressed ones, etc., maybe even a higher-res version of the same master (if available) seems a good one, though and might mitigate this?

A caution - much as with Ludwig's review of MS200/600, etc. the other day, I generally find I don't hear much of a difference with electronically produced music closed mic'd in a studio, it always seems to be more apparent in any comparison of hi-fi gear, let alone one of this type, with acoustically produced instruments/voices in a real acoustic space, if that makes sense?

Hope that helps a bit?

Cheers,

James


HC: 861v4/ID40/LPS, DSP5000, DSP5000VC, DSP3100, SW1600, HD621, Oppo BDP-105, Sony VPL-HW55ES
2-Channel: Oppo BDP-105, TEAC VRDS-7/Trichord Clock 3/PSU, 551, Quad 303, Harbeth Compact 7ES-3, Kimber cables, Russ Andrews mains and supports.
Previous Meridian: 5000C, 5200SL, 7200.2, 6000, 562V.2, 568.2mm, 800v4, 808.2i, 818v2/v3, 861v8, 502
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 655
Likes: 1
Paranoid android
Paranoid android
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 655
Likes: 1
In theory ABX testing is the way to go , but there are many detractors to this, , even simple AB testing, including Robert Stuart himself.... (he has presented papers on this at AES)

Similarly, AES Fellow J. Robert Stuart stated in his landmark papers �Estimating the Significance of Errors in Audio Systems� and �Predicting the Audibility, Detectability and Loudness of Errors in Audio Systems� that �A/B testing using program material and particularly musical program is fraught with difficulties. . .the author sets out some reasons why the �objective� approaches of A/B listening and null-testing may be flawedd.�

In reality , expectation bias and a belief system are enough for us to detect differences that don't actually exist.

The thing is , that if you do believe one thing is better than another , it DOES exist for YOU.. it is a truism.

For eg , some folk will swear blind that tea out a china mug tastes better than out of a tin , and they will spend vast amounts of money tracking down or purchasing the best china to get that better taste ..whereas the tea poured out of the cosy is the same tea.

There are also phenomena that cannot be measured
A significant percentage of people hear a tone that is between 2 actual tones , ie they will hear a 1.5k tone between , lets say a 1 and 2k tone. This tone does not exist - yet it can be heard?

I have learned in hifi to allow each person the leeway to believe what they like .. those that pay for what others consider "foo" do not need saving from themselves.

I myself like to do level matched AB testing where possible to differentiate if a potential purchase is 'better" than another or to discern differences. but I also am susceptible to expectation bias , so longer term listening is also part of it.. and ultimately my ears (and thus my brain) are the final determinant of what I like or how I spend on what...

Here's a test - close your eyes and get someone in the room to turn on and off the display on your DSP speakers , sometimes with a "false" change (Ie say they changed but they didnt)

I will swear blind there is a difference if I do it myself , but that is "sighted" (off is better) , but have never really had the gumption to get my wife or kid to do it with random change/no change and see if I can tell which is what or even determine if there is indeed a difference.
I will do that tonight....



Roon/Tidal, SBT, Trinnov ST2 , Twin Devialet D premiers, Vivid Audio Giya G1 Spirits, dedicated and treated room.
Meridian gear: 568.2mm and DSP5000's acting as TV speakers.
Joined: Apr 2012
Posts: 3,177
Likes: 171
Hooloovoo
Hooloovoo
Joined: Apr 2012
Posts: 3,177
Likes: 171
Rodney,

I think much of that is very true, and am aware of some of Bob Stuart's views on blind testing. It seems such things, although they are nice in theory, might well be flawed in terms of human psycho acoustic perception/psychology, which makes them more subjective (even if it's on a subconscious level) and less objectively scientific than they might otherwise seem?

Personally, like you, my ears/brain are always the final arbiters, as I'm the one who has to live with any choice I make. That said, I never spend money or time on anything I don't perceive as actually making a difference and I've learned, although I do trust my ears, to listen to changes in systems and other things over a longer period than just an AB dem, impressions often need to be formed over time (which I'm guessing is really a form of averaging minute variations in listening factors/impressions?) which is why I believe home dems to be invaluable.

The thing which fascinated me about my original impression of the differences here is I wasn't expecting there to be one, knowing at least in theory how accuraterip works, and seeing that I had a positive result on the particular rips in question.

I'd not heard of there being people who can hear tones in between those others can perceive - not sure I completely follow you, I assumed the ear was capable of hearing any frequency coming it's way ,within the audible spectrum, on an infinite scale, but I may have misunderstood, could you expand on that, it's potentially fascinating?


HC: 861v4/ID40/LPS, DSP5000, DSP5000VC, DSP3100, SW1600, HD621, Oppo BDP-105, Sony VPL-HW55ES
2-Channel: Oppo BDP-105, TEAC VRDS-7/Trichord Clock 3/PSU, 551, Quad 303, Harbeth Compact 7ES-3, Kimber cables, Russ Andrews mains and supports.
Previous Meridian: 5000C, 5200SL, 7200.2, 6000, 562V.2, 568.2mm, 800v4, 808.2i, 818v2/v3, 861v8, 502
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 2,492
Senior Shouting Officer
Senior Shouting Officer
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 2,492
Originally Posted by Rodney Gold
For eg , some folk will swear blind that tea out a china mug tastes better than out of a tin , and they will spend vast amounts of money tracking down or purchasing the best china to get that better taste, whereas the tea poured out of the cosy is the same tea.
Actually,the same drinks do taste differently from different vessels. The thickness of the vessel dictates the amount of air taken in with the drink which in turn has a signifiacnt influence on the taste. Here there a clear underpinning reason - I'm struggling with above however.


Main system - Sources (Kodi-HTPC, Vero 4k, FireTV, Sat) into Trinnov Altitude 32 (8-16) (+Roon), Trinnov Amplitude 8 amp & Vivid Audio (Giya G3, V1.5) and REL Stentor III speakers. Others: F80 + Raspberry Pi and other Pi systems.
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 8,816
Likes: 87
President of the Imperial Galactic Government
President of the Imperial Galactic Government
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 8,816
Likes: 87
I think there are two things... short term and long term term listening.

For me, short term is about a quick test of whether there is a difference.

Long term is about whether I like the difference.

Back to the proposed test... I suppose bias might get in the way. Placebos might be useful.
E.g. If a user with strong bias towards there being an effect might report a preference even if they were given 5 identical tracks... i.e. the same track 5 times.

So, it could be a really good study of both ripping tech and psychology. Anyone got a son/daughter heading to college to study brain stuff?

Keeping it simple I think the test proposed could still be useful or at least interesting.


Rgds,
Nick


Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 655
Likes: 1
Paranoid android
Paranoid android
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts: 655
Likes: 1
This is from Tichener Difference Tones

Originally Posted by Titchener's Experimental Psychology (1901-1905)
What a Difference Tone Is

When two pure tones are played together, it sometimes sounds as though a third tone is also present. For example, a person simultaneously hearing two loud tones of 800 and 1000 hertz may also report hearing another, quieter tone at about the pitch one would expect from a 200 hz stimulus. More generally, if two generating tones (or primary tones) of frequency U (for the upper tone) and L (for the lower tone) are played together, people will under some conditions report hearing a difference tone (or first difference tone) that sounds like a tone presented at frequency U - L, despite the fact that waveform analysis may show no sound wave at that frequency.

Similarly, people sometimes report hearing, in addition to or instead of the first difference tone, a second difference tone at approximately the pitch one would expect from a stimulus of frequency 2L - U (600 Hz, if the generating tones are 800 and1000 Hz). Titchener also describes a third difference tone at 3L - U and a summation tone at U + L. Other investigators report tones at 3L - 2U, 4L - 3U, 2U - 2L, 3U - 3L, and other frequencies. As a class these are known as combination tones. In stimuli with prominent overtones (overtones have a frequency that is an integer multiple of the fundamental frequency of the stimulus, such as 2U, 3U, 4U, etc.), people sometimes report hearing combination tones arising from the overtones.

The tones the ppl hear do not exist in reality smile

I use dBpoweramp to rip - accessing the AccurateRip DB
I have used EAC, Jriver, Mediamonkey to do rips too, I haven't compared the RIPS.. but do not find that one is better than another.

I have also used various players, Like Logitech media server, Jriver, Media Monkey, etc. and HAVE compared them back to back as I have 2 computers in my system, and considering it's all digital, it's easy to synch up each and swap between them without level matching etc. I prefer Jriver, but only because of its UI and not any sonic difference (I have not noticed a difference when using any player as long as it's playing bit perfect).

I would like to take part in the test as I can easily AB any 2 rips...


Roon/Tidal, SBT, Trinnov ST2 , Twin Devialet D premiers, Vivid Audio Giya G1 Spirits, dedicated and treated room.
Meridian gear: 568.2mm and DSP5000's acting as TV speakers.
Joined: Apr 2012
Posts: 3,177
Likes: 171
Hooloovoo
Hooloovoo
Joined: Apr 2012
Posts: 3,177
Likes: 171
Thanks for the info on Tichener, I'll have a more in depth read later when I can fully absorb!

Yeah, I'm up for it, as long as the methodology is good and done over sufficient time. How would be best? Maybe listen to both/all tracks an equal number of times over a few days/weeks and give them a mark/preference each time, then add the results together to form an overall scoring for each track?


HC: 861v4/ID40/LPS, DSP5000, DSP5000VC, DSP3100, SW1600, HD621, Oppo BDP-105, Sony VPL-HW55ES
2-Channel: Oppo BDP-105, TEAC VRDS-7/Trichord Clock 3/PSU, 551, Quad 303, Harbeth Compact 7ES-3, Kimber cables, Russ Andrews mains and supports.
Previous Meridian: 5000C, 5200SL, 7200.2, 6000, 562V.2, 568.2mm, 800v4, 808.2i, 818v2/v3, 861v8, 502
Page 3 of 4 1 2 3 4

Moderated by  Carl, Duncs, ncpl 

Link Copied to Clipboard
Who's Online Now
2 members (3dit0r, Carl), 711 guests, and 3 robots.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Newest Members
Kiran1103, Tony999, PhilP, Grover, Humberto
5,503 Registered Users
Top Posters(30 Days)
HugoF 10
Gemeni 8
Top Posters
VirusKiller 12,733
ncpl 8,816
Carl 8,506
Fiddler 8,364
Ian 7,950
Forum Statistics
Forums18
Topics31,253
Posts297,454
Members5,503
Most Online4,788
May 22nd, 2026
Meridian  |  Media Centre  |  Support  |  Firmware Release Notes  |  RSS Systems  |  RSS Streaming  |  RSS Restaurant

Website Provided by Mr Tech Guy - Resolute Audio Visual Limited © 2026

Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 8.0.1
(Release build 20251126)
Responsive Width:

PHP: 8.5.12 Page Time: 0.034s Queries: 39 (0.024s) Memory: 0.6995 MB (Peak: 0.8056 MB) Data Comp: Off Server Time: 2026-11-17 23:16:43 UTC
Valid HTML 5 and Valid CSS