Sorry guys, for some reason when this got branched off from the other thread I thought I'd subscribed but never did, so I missed this fascinating discussion! It's genuinely nice to see at least the possibility of difference being rationally and civilly debated (I've been on forums where the mere mention of a cable would result in all-out war).

Nick, you asked a while back whether my initial impression of this was based on a comparison of the same track - it was, and there's a thread a while back when I queried the difference at the time, with someone kindly checking the checksums, which they concluded were identical. The odd thing is that I wasn't consciously comparing the two tracks for differences to start with, it was more accidental that I heard a difference, which I then explored consciously.

In any case, I'd have to do a longer term, randomised test (perhaps along the lines you suggest) to really work out whether it was objective or whether, for whatever reason the first time I heard a difference I was in a bad mood, tired, tilting my head a fraction, or sitting in a slightly different position to normal, etc., etc. At the time, past the initial day or so of comparisons, I didn't have too much time, so just went back to using Control:Mac.

I'm up for the kind of blind testing on the forum you're suggesting though, might be really interesting. I do understand the earlier objection, though - I think what was being suggested is that expectation bias is also true for those who expect no difference (if you truly believe there can be no difference, will you be open to hearing it whether it's there or not?). The suggestion of lower bitrate samples, compressed ones, etc., maybe even a higher-res version of the same master (if available) seems a good one, though and might mitigate this?

A caution - much as with Ludwig's review of MS200/600, etc. the other day, I generally find I don't hear much of a difference with electronically produced music closed mic'd in a studio, it always seems to be more apparent in any comparison of hi-fi gear, let alone one of this type, with acoustically produced instruments/voices in a real acoustic space, if that makes sense?

Hope that helps a bit?

Cheers,

James


HC: 861v4/ID40/LPS, DSP5000, DSP5000VC, DSP3100, SW1600, HD621, Oppo BDP-105, Sony VPL-HW55ES
2-Channel: Oppo BDP-105, TEAC VRDS-7/Trichord Clock 3/PSU, 551, Quad 303, Harbeth Compact 7ES-3, Kimber cables, Russ Andrews mains and supports.
Previous Meridian: 5000C, 5200SL, 7200.2, 6000, 562V.2, 568.2mm, 800v4, 808.2i, 818v2/v3, 861v8, 502