Indeed... I am a bit puzzled. There is an obvious temptation to ridicule any findings concerning the possible differences in ripping. It's all 1's and 0's etc.

So, I suggest we all have a listen to some tracks that are ripped via EAC, dBpa and laptop with battery etc.

Put them up and see if anyone can rate them. Get an independent to host the files and you can join in too. No one can have any expectation if they don't know what the files are.

If you are worried that some folks will hear nothing because they expect to hear nothing then we can throw some diff tracks in... e.g a FLAC made from a 128 MP3 track. Should be obvious but if you don't know which one it is then you'd better listen.

I don't believe I have seen this done on the web before.

I am happy to host if it helps.


Rgds,
Nick