Steve,

Let me add my tuppence.

1) I do not appreciate your re-posting the paragraph that Carl edited out. I'm going to let that lie for the time being, but the other moderators might not.

2)
Quote
Is it an unofficial tech support to provide information that many of the dealers are/were ignorant of or is it a gathering place for Meridian owners and fans (and enemies) for social debating and general chit chat? I'm unsure...
It is both. Frankly and IMHO, it provides customer support that Meridian should be providing itself. I have wondered on more than one occasion whether Meridian - a company that had to be bought out on more than one occasion because it wasn't a good *business* - would have survived without the brand publicity and support of the used market that the forum gave it.

3a) This is a privately owned forum, based in the UK and subject to UK laws. The forum is not collectively owned; it was created and owned by George Mills and the ownership passed to Duncan Rolfe when George decided to give it up. In other words Duncan can do what he likes with the forum. Having said that, and as Carl has posted, these changes did not come about purely from private discussions: they are a solution to a combination of (i) requests from forum members and (ii) problems faced by the moderators (such as how to allow off-topic posts without cluttering up the main forum).

3b) Discussion (and the promotion of the sale) of third party DSP algorithms which make use of reverse engineering has effectively been banned on this forum because part of the process through which these algorithms have been developed almost certainly involve breaches of Meridian's intellectual property (under UK law at the least) and because the forum owner (Duncan) *could* be liable for permitting such open discussion. This is a horribly grey area. Some individuals are more "liberal-minded" than UK law permits (Consider attitudes to file-sharing, DVD/Blu-Ray ripping, reverse engineering for profit).

4) You might be surprised at the amount of time and effort that the forum administrators (Duncan and Carl) put in. It dwarfs the time I spend as a moderator.

5)
Quote
are Meridian high end hi-fi manufacturers or are they manufacturers of hi-fi for high end (high income) consumers? I very much fear a trend towards the later...
Time will tell. I hope not, but it is a possibility.



Roon Developer and ex-moderator of this Forum
I am #25 in the HH1 photo of fame.