|
|
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 2,474 Likes: 18
Senior Shouting Officer
|
|
Senior Shouting Officer
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 2,474 Likes: 18 |
Ronnie, Could you link to where a proper analyzing of the Spotify mobile Android/iOS client is? I remember they had only 160kbit in the beginning and they added the possibility to 96kbit later. And I've had several times where the bandwidth is not enough for 160kbit and selecting 96kbit in the mobile client solves the streaming. So I would like to see some proof about this one. 
DSP8000SE, DSP7200SEHC, DSP5200SE sides, DSP7200SE rears, 861v8, 210, Sim2 Ultranero 4, Stewart Cinecurve 2.35:1, XEIT CM-5E Anamorphic lens, Dune HD Duo Cinema 8K and Wireworld Platinum 48G HDMI -> UHD722 -> Shunyata Omega Ethernet. Shunyata/Furutech power-cables/filters. SR Master Fuse@861v8. Uptone Etherregen with 10MHz OCXO clock.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 2,474 Likes: 18
Senior Shouting Officer
|
|
Senior Shouting Officer
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 2,474 Likes: 18 |
DSP8000SE, DSP7200SEHC, DSP5200SE sides, DSP7200SE rears, 861v8, 210, Sim2 Ultranero 4, Stewart Cinecurve 2.35:1, XEIT CM-5E Anamorphic lens, Dune HD Duo Cinema 8K and Wireworld Platinum 48G HDMI -> UHD722 -> Shunyata Omega Ethernet. Shunyata/Furutech power-cables/filters. SR Master Fuse@861v8. Uptone Etherregen with 10MHz OCXO clock.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 4,014
Vogon Civil Servant
|
|
Vogon Civil Servant
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 4,014 |
I get it Crion......you're a fan of Spotify.......but a little objectivity would go a long way......... Just because Meridian claim to make the best CD Player, that doesn't mean that we should just accept it on blind faith......and just because Spotify claim to Stream at 320kbps (or 160kbps on mobile devices), doesn't mean that we should accept their claims on blind faith........especially when many of their Claims have already been shown to be misleading.........and they've been unable to offer a credible defense Objective Listening is the way to verify any claim..........and in a similar way, Spotify's claims should be tested independently and objectively.......which is what the above referred posts are doing Given all the recent negative publicity about the real Bit Rates being delivered by Spotify.......and almost more importantly by Spotify's own impotent and almost deliberately misleading media responses....... then I would suggest that it is you who should be offering the "proof" of Spotify's Bit Rates on Mobile devicesA simple Net Traffic monitor on your Phone and a look at the File Sizes of cached downloads should tell you a lot For other users here, take a look at the link below (and the many links and media follow ups to it).....and make up your own minds about Spotify's credibility on this whole subject Only 35 of the 115 tested tracks are in high quality.
I can give you a rough estimate: an ordinary dual-core computer can convert an 10-track, 40-minute album from FLAC to q9 ogg (320 kbps) in two minutes (at most). That is 12 seconds for one track.
15,000,000*12/(60*60*24*365*2)=2.854
So it only takes 3 home computers to convert Spotify�s whole 15-million tracks catalog into 320 kbps ogg files in two years time.
So why Spotify hasn�t done this yet? Honestly I have no idea. The only explanation I can imagine is to save bandwidth, but that seems to be too trivial a reason for not delivering goods to paid customers who took it for granted since 2009. http://www.spotifyclassical.com/2011/07/spotify-bitrategate-story-so-far.htmlAlso see the additional User Tests and Comments at the bottom of this link http://www.spotifyclassical.com/2011/07/dear-spotify-please-give-us-premium.html
-
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 4,014
Vogon Civil Servant
|
|
Vogon Civil Servant
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 4,014 |
What quality does Spotify stream in? We use the Ogg Vorbis format for streaming. There are three quality ratings that we use:
q3 (~96 kbps) q5 (~160 kbps) q9 (~320 kbps)
Note: not all tracks are currently available in high bitrate.
Desktop: Streams are q5 quality. Premium subscribers can enable higher bit rate streaming at q9 from the preferences menu.
Mobile: A higher quality q5 is offered, along with a �low bandwidth� option of q3. You can choose separate qualities ratings for streaming and synching in the More tab of your Spotify mobile app. I do find it strange that the Defaults on both the Spotify Desktop and Mobile Clients are for the lower bit rates........even for Premium Account holders It's up to the User to go into the Settings and change the Default Enough said from me......people can read the links, do their own investigations and make up their own minds on Spotify's Credibility
-
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 2,474 Likes: 18
Senior Shouting Officer
|
|
Senior Shouting Officer
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 2,474 Likes: 18 |
I checked the 160kbit streaming when the iOS mobile Spotify client was first released because I was checking wether it would stream 320kbit to mobile with wifi (wishful thinking  Sure I can check the android client as well but I think they will be exactly the same ie. Selectable between 160kbit or 96kbit stream for mobile users. There are some doubts about the Grooveshark service regarding legality, soundquality and MP3 tags expressed since users themselves updates/rips a part of the music archive. Even though only a part of Spotify 15M songs are available in 320kbit atleast they were all created from a lossless master provided by the record company with proper tags. But ofcourse the sooner they get going on converting the rest of the tracks to 320kbit the better.
DSP8000SE, DSP7200SEHC, DSP5200SE sides, DSP7200SE rears, 861v8, 210, Sim2 Ultranero 4, Stewart Cinecurve 2.35:1, XEIT CM-5E Anamorphic lens, Dune HD Duo Cinema 8K and Wireworld Platinum 48G HDMI -> UHD722 -> Shunyata Omega Ethernet. Shunyata/Furutech power-cables/filters. SR Master Fuse@861v8. Uptone Etherregen with 10MHz OCXO clock.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 4,014
Vogon Civil Servant
|
|
Vogon Civil Servant
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 4,014 |
I hear what you're saying Crion about the User can "select" between 160kbps and Default 96kbps on their iOS / Android Device
However, as described earlier, in a similar way on the Desktop Player, the Spotify Premium User can select away from the Default 160kbps to the Higher Quality 320kbps Stream
However, until people have gone to the trouble to check recently, most people have been under the impression that selecting that HQ Stream on the Desktop resulted in ALL the Music being in 320kbps format...........the Reality is that only 25% of the Content is in that higher bit rate quality
Similarly, people are toggling the menu on their Mobile devices and think that by selecting the 160kbps option, that is what they are receiving.............but when they test with a Net Traffic Monitor or the File Size of the Cached Download.........they see Traffic and File Sizes consistent with the lower 96kbps........try it for yourself
As for Grooveshark........the only reason I've mentioned it (as per the start of the post) is for all the Euro and other Countries without Spotify........after all, Spotify is still only available in 8 Countries worldwide........with even the large populations in Germany, Austria, Russia, Denmark, Australia etc., left out in the cold...........Grooveshark provides a similar service, has been in operation longer than Spotify and appears to be available worldwide
As for those who truly want higher quality 320kbps for most/all of their Music, then MOG appears to be only option.......with the caveats already mentioned about VPN's and US Credit Cards
-
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 2,474 Likes: 18
Senior Shouting Officer
|
|
Senior Shouting Officer
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 2,474 Likes: 18 |
I have 64 invites available for: USA, Sweden, Norway, Finland, UK, France, Spain and the Netherlands. Just send me a PM with your e-mail address and watch your spam folder 
DSP8000SE, DSP7200SEHC, DSP5200SE sides, DSP7200SE rears, 861v8, 210, Sim2 Ultranero 4, Stewart Cinecurve 2.35:1, XEIT CM-5E Anamorphic lens, Dune HD Duo Cinema 8K and Wireworld Platinum 48G HDMI -> UHD722 -> Shunyata Omega Ethernet. Shunyata/Furutech power-cables/filters. SR Master Fuse@861v8. Uptone Etherregen with 10MHz OCXO clock.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 2,474 Likes: 18
Senior Shouting Officer
|
|
Senior Shouting Officer
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 2,474 Likes: 18 |
Since pointing out the 320kbit disparity on various forums a bunch of newspapers also cought up with the "news" and we are seeing real progress now. There is also a way to check Spotify's bitrate directly on Mac, see below: I would also prefer more transparency in the bitrate of the songs. On the Mac, when you make a playlist available offline, the 'Console' application shows the bitrate for those songs. I would like to see that kind of information in the Spotify application itself. Btw i love Spotify, but the bitrate issue has been bothering me just like it did to you. Using console, I recheck my 115-track 320k test playlist, five tracks already cached so can't tell. Out of the 110 remaining tracks, 60 of them are now at 320 kbps.
And the pattern is clear, most popular tracks have been converted in the past few weeks since my initial test, or, more likely, since the original post was published. The relatively less popular tracks generated by Spotibot are still mostly at 160 kbps
DSP8000SE, DSP7200SEHC, DSP5200SE sides, DSP7200SE rears, 861v8, 210, Sim2 Ultranero 4, Stewart Cinecurve 2.35:1, XEIT CM-5E Anamorphic lens, Dune HD Duo Cinema 8K and Wireworld Platinum 48G HDMI -> UHD722 -> Shunyata Omega Ethernet. Shunyata/Furutech power-cables/filters. SR Master Fuse@861v8. Uptone Etherregen with 10MHz OCXO clock.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 4,014
Vogon Civil Servant
|
|
Vogon Civil Servant
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 4,014 |
For those outside of the limited Spotify covered countries.........
1) Once the User has established a MOG Account using a US Credit Card (USUnlocked.com and other options), and set up their User Name and Password Logons.......then a VPN is not required, i.e. it will work with your normal IP Address, whatever country you live in
This applies to both the Desktop and Mobile Players........it also applies after closing the Apps and later re-opening them.......and indeed after Re-booting PC or Phone
2) Having played around with the MOG Service for about 3-4 weeks now, I can confirm (using Net Traffic monitors and other means) that about 80%+ of their Streaming is at 320kbps.......the rest is at 256kbps......with the 256kbps being limited to one particular label only
Likewise, the Mobile Service is at 320kbps......i.e. the same quality as the Desktop application.....again confirmed by Net Traffic monitors........good 3G or HSPA coverage required to maintain stutter free streaming at this rate.......else, a lower bit rate of 64-128kbps can be selected
Mobile Downloads are also mostly at 320kbps (some 256kbps).........easy to confirm from downloaded File Sizes..........compares well on Shure headphones to Spotify's 160kbps max
3) Selected about 30 Artists across a mixture of Genres.........Rock, Folk, Jazz, Soul, Blues, R&B
Searched for their Albums......and generally found that the "Main" Albums from those Artists were available on MOG..........by comparison, sometimes these "Main" or "Core" Albums were missing on the Spotify UK service........Bob Dylan (Highway 61, Blonde on Blonde, etc. all missing) & Van Morisson (Veedon Fleece, Too Late to Stop Now, etc.) being easy examples, with none or few of their Core Albums being available on Spotify........just some "Best of's..." or some "Live" or Tribute albums
Thought some might be interested in these results..........
-
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 4,014
Vogon Civil Servant
|
|
Vogon Civil Servant
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 4,014 |
I wonder how many Spotify Users are aware of this little one..........i.e. that your Spotify will grab part of your Bandwidth and use that to share Music with others........even when you are not using the App The statement below is from Spotify themselves........with the other statements from people who followed what the knock on implications were Why does Spotify use so many internet connections? Spotify uses a peer-to-peer network along with streaming servers to stream music. This is why you see multiple connections to other Spotify users. Was less than pleasantly surprised to see that when Spotify wasn�t playing audio, it was using my network connection. A lot.
Google searching this time uncovered something not immediately disclosed by Spotify: the application employs built-in peer-to-peer networking technology to share streaming music from its cache on my computer with other Spotify users who want the same tunes, presumably taking the load off Spotify�s own servers.
There�s almost no mention of this P2P functionality on Spotify�s own site. And no way to throttle or turn off the upstream P2P use in either the free or paid version which, probably, is a key part of Spotify�s business and technology model. (As is a large local hard disk cache, reportedly a minimum of 1GB. At least hard drive space is cheap.)
Spotify, effectively, shifts some of its bandwidth costs to users which, in a perfect world without relatively new Comcast, Verizon Wireless and AT&T bandwidth caps or tiered pricing, would not matter. Yet it does. No �free� streaming service is worth the risk of pissing off the Xfinity limit police and losing my Internet service.
True price of free Spotify? Slowing down my system even when I�m not actively using the program, and potential cancellation of web access. At least it uninstalled cleanly. But I have experienced a noticeable slowing in my internet speeds ever since I installed Spotify on my computer. When my wife and I both have Spotify running on each of our computers, web pages load noticeably slower than they would otherwise.
-
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 220
Hitchhiker
|
|
Hitchhiker
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 220 |
I wasn't, for one. How do you stop this? Will moving it to trash work? Thanks,
Ed.
G91, G68, 5x DSP33, SW1600, HD621. Red F80 and dock.
|
|
|
|
2 members (Floris, MarkQV),
813
guests, and
3
robots. |
|
Key:
Admin,
Global Mod,
Mod
|
|
|
Forums18
Topics31,249
Posts297,436
Members5,503
| |
Most Online4,788 May 22nd, 2026
|
|
|
|