We must put the Which? Consumers Association findings into perspective.

They are a consumers association who deal with consumer matters and their reviews are performed in a controlled environment using equipment which would be typical of UK consumers setup, ie size and viewing distance. Many people on this forum are not using typical consumers equipment.

Quote
Our expert viewing panel watched a selection of 17 films from a variety of studios, both made before and after the advent of the Blu-ray format. Each title was viewed simultaneously on DVD and Blu-ray disc on two identical Full-HD Sony TVs (Bravia KDL-40W4500) and played back on two identical Sony Blu-ray players (BDP-S550). Blu-ray players can play both high-definition and regular DVD discs.

When watching a DVD movie on a player connected to an HDTV via HDMI you have the option to adjust the settings and �up-scale� the picture. For comparisons sake we left the 'up-scaling' option off, so the DVD was watched in its regular 576p resolution setting.

The whole point of the review is that Bluray can do better. Clearly there are some Bluray pressings that look far better than DVD whilst some others do not look as good on consumer equipment. As far as Which? is concerned, all Bluray discs should look better as this is one of the biggest selling points of Bluray over DVD. It immaterial whether the differences can only be seen or heard on �xxk equipment as this is not what most UK consumers own. What matters to them is that UK consumers are getting a fair deal on what to expect from Bluray on typical home equipment, in this case, approx �1000 of TV and DVD player.

Which is exactly the findings that will benefit us the most as Which? are one of the few establishments who can fire with big guns and actually shame companies or champion legislation changes to make companies improve their products.


Meridian owner since 1992
Prime & PSU, Focal Elear headphones, Roon (ROCK 8Gi5 NUC), Explorer 1 & 2, F80. 200/203, various Sonos (via Roon).