|
|
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 515 Likes: 3
Paranoid android
|
|
Paranoid android
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 515 Likes: 3 |
I recently purchase (3) DSP3100, that I would like to use as left, center and right speaker, in a minimal surround system. I`m trying to avoid having to buy a Meridian controller/processor (no money and I`m not really interested in processing the signal), and keep the setup as simple and straightforward as possible.
All my sources are digital, some are two channel only (Lossless music files from iTune on iMac via optical cable), some are multichannel (Samsung DTB-H260F digital HDTV tuner, Samusung BD-C6500 Blu-ray Player).
Everything is connected to an auto switch (Octava HDS4-V13, 4x1 HDMI Switch with SPDIF Digital audio Routing).
Reading the Meridian manual of the DSP3100, I understand how to create a simple TWO channel system, by connecting the left (or right) speaker to the SPDIF out of the Octava, as a MASTER, then from the digital OUT of the first speaker to the other speaker digital IN.
My question is: if a DSP speaker is able to isolate the left or right channel for a digital signal, and reproduce either one or the other by selecting it with the remote control, why cannot that speaker be able to isolate also the other channels of a surround signal (5.1 or 7.1), and selectively play any of them?
I`ve been reading posts about how to split the digital signal from a HDMI source into (3) or (4) SPDIF - with mods from Shawn, a Meridian HD621, etc - but I was wondering if the speaker itself wouldn`t be able to do the job?
As far as I understand, the posts mentioned above are actually discussing how to extract an UNCOMPRESSED digital signal from each surround audio channel of a HDMI source. But I would already be happy if I can have the DSP speakers reproduce compressed digital surround signal from SPDIF, without adding another controller/processor and spending another $3000.
I`m not sure all that makes any sense: I`m new to Meridian products, please pardon my naivety and thank you for your help.
Jerome Music: NUC + ROCK + QObuz > MS600 > G65 > DSP8000SE + DSP5200HC.SL + DSP5200SE rears Movies: Apple TV > HD621 > G65 > DSP8000SE + DSP5200HC.SL + DSP5200SE rears
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 1,351 Likes: 1
Working on the ultimate question
|
|
Working on the ultimate question
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 1,351 Likes: 1 |
Jerome,
that is a good question. Dealers tend to position dual DSP speakers (LR) + a digital player such as Sonos or Squeeze for a minimal 2 channel setup.
However, Meridian processors are well known for their LR+Center "Trifield" mode, which takes 2 channel stereo and creates a LCR signal.
M. probably wants to have its DSP customers buy more than 3 DSP speakers, so ... you probably need a processor. Read the HD621 manual carefully, IMHO while it isn't designed for what you want, there is a slim possibility it might work,too.
But the good new is, G61/G68 processors have never been cheaper... they are very cheap on Audiogon at the moment, the cheapest M. processors tend only to have digital DSP outputs, not a worry for you!
MJT
Primary: 818v3+ID41, M6 stereo pair, M SpeakerLink cabling, Sonos+96kHz Cullen, silver DSW HT: Marantz prepro, 271, DSP3300, 8K SE FL/FR pair, DSP M6x2, DSP320x4 (ceiling), black DSW, 520 RL/RR rear in-walls Living Room: G65, 640 L/R in-walls, UHD722, MS600 Vac. Home: G61, HD621, 4xDSP3100, DSP3100HC MDMS:NUC/ROCK+TrueNAS Core 12.0 ZFS file server
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 4,579 Likes: 25
President of the Imperial Galactic Government
|
|
President of the Imperial Galactic Government
Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 4,579 Likes: 25 |
Hi Jerome
Welcome to the forum.
The bad news is that it's not really practically possible to do what you want without a processor.
A multichannel bitstream is a different beast to a two channel PCM stream. The DSP speakers can work with the latter, but not the former.
A processor, or source which can internally decode this bitstream, is required. Leaving aside the processor option, and assuming that your sources can internally decode to the relevant number of channels for output over HDMI, you'll need something like Shawn Fogg's modified Clux to get the decoded PCM streams from HDMI to 3x SPDIF for the DSP speakers.
At that point, you'll have a SDPIF feed for the L/R pair, and a SPDIF feed for the centre. You now have the substantial problem that there's no way to coordinate the volume levels of the main pair and the centre, nor the timing delays between them. This is why a processor is necessary.
So, in theory there are workarounds, but in practice, it's really not workable. I'd keep the centre in a cupboard and start saving towards a 568.2mm if costs are important. Should be a lot less than $3000 (indeed, around $1200 on Audiogon?) but it will be a real upgrade for you in numerous other ways beyond the practical concerns here.
Cheers
George
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 326
Hitchhiker
|
|
Hitchhiker
Joined: Feb 2010
Posts: 326 |
as I understand it, the speakers can extract a left or right channel from a stereo signal on a coax cable. this is the simple kind of stereo that a CD player would produce for example.
when a DSP speaker is used as a centre it's basically just taking a left signal our of a stereo pair, the right signal being for the subwoofer (rear L&R are just LR off the rear coax cable).
what we're not talking here is dolby digital. a DSP speaker doesn't know what dolby digital or dts are, nor does it understand how to extract the 6/8 channels from that signal. that's what the Meridian processor does. it's got code that takes the dolby digital signal and split it out into 6 or 8 channels of simple stereo and then feeds these stereo pairs to the DSP speakers who don't realise they're doing centre or rear duty, they just play the signal given to them.
I don't think you can get a centre signal without a Meridian processor. the reason you'll need a Meridian rather than anyone else's is because no-one else's processors output in digital.
the HD621 takes the 2/6/8 channel audio feed from a HDMI source and split it into 4 digital output channels. a modded clux does the same. you could use this to feed your LR and centre speakers, but then you'd need some way of keeping the speakers in sync together and you'd have no adjustment of individual channels etc. this is what a processor would be doing for you.
If you are only interested in classic dolby digital then you should be able to pick up a 2nd hand older 500 series processor which can do the decoding, do some adjustments for distance and level and then feed that into your speakers.
if you want high bitrate lossless audio (truehd, or dts-ma for example) then you'd the HD621 (or modded clux etc) and a more expensive processor capable of accepting the digital input (a 568.2mm or above).
does that make sense?
dave
Lounge: LG 55B6v, Some Denon receiver, Anthony Gallo Reference AV mains, Totem Dreamcatcher centre, SVS PC-4000, AppleTV4K Office: Audioquest Dragonfly, Cyrus 6DAC, Monitor Audio CPW Gold Headphones: NuForce HDP, Audeze LCD-2, Sennheiser HD6XX, B&O H6mk2
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 515 Likes: 3
Paranoid android
|
|
Paranoid android
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 515 Likes: 3 |
Thank you all for your replies: I think I understand a little bit better what kind of digital signal we're talking about. It seems like, as suggested, I'll have to save some money and purchase an additional Meridian controller, old or new.
Jerome Music: NUC + ROCK + QObuz > MS600 > G65 > DSP8000SE + DSP5200HC.SL + DSP5200SE rears Movies: Apple TV > HD621 > G65 > DSP8000SE + DSP5200HC.SL + DSP5200SE rears
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: May 2001
Posts: 3,140 Likes: 24
Hooloovoo
|
|
Hooloovoo
Joined: May 2001
Posts: 3,140 Likes: 24 |
You could pick up a 565z3 (that's the version that can decode DD and DTS - and it does Trifield with width control  ) for peanuts and see if you like it. If you don't you can sell it on at minmal loss, if you do then you could trade up for a 568.2mm (or better) likewise. Sounds like your Octava switch should be able to resolve the lack of inputs on the 565.
In the spirit of Spinaltap, I would like to confirm that I am not involved in the corrupt theft of a global sport.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 515 Likes: 3
Paranoid android
|
|
Paranoid android
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 515 Likes: 3 |
You could pick up a 565z3 (that's the version that can decode DD and DTS - and it does Trifield with width control  ) for peanuts and see if you like it. If you don't you can sell it on at minmal loss, if you do then you could trade up for a 568.2mm (or better) likewise. Sounds like your Octava switch should be able to resolve the lack of inputs on the 565. Thank you Gianni for the suggestion: what is the difference between a 565 and a 561? They seem to be available at approximately the same price.
Jerome Music: NUC + ROCK + QObuz > MS600 > G65 > DSP8000SE + DSP5200HC.SL + DSP5200SE rears Movies: Apple TV > HD621 > G65 > DSP8000SE + DSP5200HC.SL + DSP5200SE rears
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: May 2000
Posts: 8,364 Likes: 14
President of the Imperial Galactic Government
|
|
President of the Imperial Galactic Government
Joined: May 2000
Posts: 8,364 Likes: 14 |
You cannot run 3 or 5 speakers without a processor. You could run two with no processor and tell your BD Player to output two channel PCM only.
You won't get the most out of your 3 3100's and BD player without a 568 or better. A 565 or 561 might not even play all Bluerays.
- Fiddler (IMHO)
If you think listening to music is fun, try learning an instrument. HT: G61RSL, 4x5K, 5.5KHC, 2xSC6000, Transporter, HD621, Philips BDP7501 4K, Tivo, 65" LG OLED 4K C6 Computer: Foobar2000, 5K, Mojo, HiFiMan HE1000 V2
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 341
Hitchhiker
|
|
Hitchhiker
Joined: Aug 2007
Posts: 341 |
"At that point, you'll have a SDPIF feed for the L/R pair, and a SPDIF feed for the centre. You now have the substantial problem that there's no way to coordinate the volume levels of the main pair and the centre, nor the timing delays between them. This is why a processor is necessary."
If you mod the Oppo itself (instead of an Octava/CLUX) you have time alignment, speaker balancing, bass management and even a master volume control available on the 4x SPDIF outputs.
Shawn
.
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 8,506 Likes: 78
President of the Imperial Galactic Government
|
|
President of the Imperial Galactic Government
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 8,506 Likes: 78 |
G91A v 568.2mm Sound Quality?
Split out to new thread as it was not related to this one.
861v6+ID40, HD621, 8000.2, 7200HC, 7200.2, SKYQ Silver, PS3, PDP-LX6090, QNAP TS870-Pro (8*6TB), Roon, iPadAir2. [In Reserve] C15, MD600 (2*3TB), TwinStore RM (2*2TB)
|
|
|
|
0 members (),
369
guests, and
3
robots. |
|
Key:
Admin,
Global Mod,
Mod
|
|
|
Forums18
Topics31,249
Posts297,436
Members5,503
| |
Most Online4,788 May 22nd, 2026
|
|
|
|