Ok, I think I may have found the secret for the -3dB headroom.

It was already in the Wiki from an older test smile another awesome test if I do say myself because it was really valuable for this new bit of information.

http://www.meridianunplugged.com/wiki/index.php?pagename=TrifieldCenterEQCurves

Trifield Center EQ needs approx ~3dB of HeadRoom, especially when set to EQ3.

If you run Center EQ set to "Flat" it will not clip with the +3dB Tweak.

To test this I used a Stereo Full Scale Test signal at 3KHz (right where EQ3 boosts the most). The system was set having ALL channels at +3dB. Then I recorded center channel with Center EQ = Flat (no clip) and Center EQ = EQ3 (clip). Then I set preset -3dB on Center with Ceneter EQ = EQ3 (no clip). This is good !!

This is really not a good reason for losing 3dB on everything else (even when running Center EQ Flat in Trifield).

The only DSP Preset that does this is Trifield (Music DSP is a derivative of Trifield and has it too). Cinema etc. does not (but I didn't measure it). Only so many hours a day my wife can stand this.

Discrete movies are not "Processed". That applies to Lossy and Lossless.

So even if your a 90% Movie 10% Music person your movies pay a price for this capability in Trifield. Or if you listen in 2 Channel, you still pay for it. If Meridian must shift levels to make head room like this they should do it just in that Preset. In fact they could process the Center -3dB then tell the DSP Speaker to boost it +3dB later.

You even pay the price if you only have TWO full range speakers playing a CD !! (like the G91 test I did).

Keep this in context that we are talking awesome vs really awesome.

So if you love Trifield I suggest making sure Center EQ is set flat and run +3dB in speaker calibration on as many channels as you can. Or you can also try leaving Center EQ Default (EQ1 or EQ3 if that's your thing) and set center in Preset to -3dB in Trifield (and Music) only and run the +3dB in speaker calibration on all channels you can.

I'll try to update Wiki with this info soon.

Keep in mind also this is still no excuse (in my opinion) for doing speaker calibration in digital domain in first place. The -3dB is a seperate concern.

I will update my program to flag this so you can see the total resolution loss or clip risk for each preset. Basically if I see anything but "Flat" I will treat as if it was 3dB louder.

By the way this *might* (I said MIGHT) give a hint as to why analog sounds better at -4.0dB.


- Fiddler (IMHO)

If you think listening to music is fun, try learning an instrument.
HT: G61RSL, 4x5K, 5.5KHC, 2xSC6000, Transporter, HD621, Philips BDP7501 4K, Tivo, 65" LG OLED 4K C6
Computer: Foobar2000, 5K, Mojo, HiFiMan HE1000 V2