It can do all the cool stuff it wants to internally (apply dithering, shaping etc.) in 72 bits. But if you stretched 16 into 24 (from SPDIF input to SPDIF) output you'd be pushing the low level bits of the 16bit word (very audible bits) down into the into low level bits of a 24bit word (very inaudible rangle).

Take my DAC resolution test for example. The limit of my system is 19-20bits (period). Anything beyond that at max volume it out of reach.

Now lets say I take a 16bit file and I put something in the low bit (all 0 above it). Now if you "stretch that out" those low bits would be now in the lowest 2 bits of the 24bit word (the ones you cannot hear). Top 20 or so bits would be now be 0 (the ones you can hear). You have something you could hear now you can't.

Everything works from 0dB DOWN, the negative scale. There is a lot of history and SPDIF compatability involved.

What your doing is thinking I have say a value of 1 in a 16 bit word and the least significant bit would be set top represent it. And if you convert it to 24bit that would move to the least significant bit(s) of a 24bit word. That is not how it works.

This link helps explain some of it. It's exactly the same for 24bit. 24bit just goes 8bits MORE NEGATIVE.

If you did "stretch" 16 to 24 that would be an "Expander" which would be just as bad as over compression (which is what the article below is about).

http://www.chicagomasteringservice.com/loudness.html

Quote
In digital audio, an instantaneous moment of sound is described by a string of ones and zeroes, and there is a limit to the loudest signal that can be described numerically (for cd audio, that's a string of 16 ones). A different kind of dB scale was needed to take this into account. This is known as dBFS or full scale. As opposed to the VU scale, in which zero on the scale is the average operating level which program swings above and below, zero in dBFS is the absolute highest level allowed. It is the very top end of the scale and all usable audio program falls below it. The dBFS scale uses negative numbers to represent audio program level below the maximum zero. In studios with both types of metering present, a point on the negative dBFS scale would be correlated with a point on the dBVU scale. Typically this is something like -20 dBFS = 0 dBVU, so that "0 dB" on a VU meter would leave approximately 20dB of headroom for signal peaks on the dBFS scale.


- Fiddler (IMHO)

If you think listening to music is fun, try learning an instrument.
HT: G61RSL, 4x5K, 5.5KHC, 2xSC6000, Transporter, HD621, Philips BDP7501 4K, Tivo, 65" LG OLED 4K C6
Computer: Foobar2000, 5K, Mojo, HiFiMan HE1000 V2