Originally Posted by Ronomy
George,

Did you try multichannel input bass frequencies to make sure the -3db setting isn't there for a reason? I bet at some point you guys will run into a problem and clip. Meridian wouldn't throw away resolution to the DSP speakers if there was no reason for it. Maybe there is dither added in the DSP speakers or even gain in the DSP speakers before the DAC in the speakers. For music it probably works fine but with multichannel I bet you'll find scenes where some clipping will take place. I am surprised Meridian hasn't chimed in on this one. Then again they never did with my finding although they did say it was interesting and they would listen. They never commented after that. That was back in 2000-2001.

Ron

Ron,

I know your not reading all the posts and just catching up.

We highly suspect it's there for headroom for Center Channel boost in Presets. Which so happens to be limited to what. 3dB. If they didn't lower everthing by 3dB it would allow clipping (if someone boosted their Center Preset). But who uses +3dB on center preset?

If you boost Center Channel +3dB you'll be at 0dB FullScale. I have not measured center yet. But I did rears. Rears allows for +20dB boost and you can make them clip !! BUt I think they know rears are usually attenuated and allowed more positive range.

I'll bet an 808 doesn't attenuate 3dB when hooked direct to 8K's. I'll bet it's perfect full scale.

And the more you attenuate for Speaker Calibration the more bits your just throwing away just for the purposes of equalizing them. That's a huge cost. Only because they didn't design DSP speakers themselves to allow for an ANALOG trims. They can do analog trimming inside preamps like yours and they DO. That's why the range is allowed to go positive on analog speakers. They don't do analog Trimming with DSP Speakers and I absolutely know that and that in itself is bad. But they easily could.

Direct preset in G68 now sounds like Direct wired. Rears are always attenuated in Trifield. I'm not worried about clipping. If someone wants to do more measurements, go for it. I'm convinced this is better and I'm pretty convinced why it works (see 518 manual) and why they did it (equalization and option of center boost).


- Fiddler (IMHO)

If you think listening to music is fun, try learning an instrument.
HT: G61RSL, 4x5K, 5.5KHC, 2xSC6000, Transporter, HD621, Philips BDP7501 4K, Tivo, 65" LG OLED 4K C6
Computer: Foobar2000, 5K, Mojo, HiFiMan HE1000 V2