"When Meridian says Resolution Enhancement (16 to 24bit) their may be now some new data in the low bits (from dithering and processing) but they are still VERY low level bits (most insignificant ones). The top 16 most significant should be more or less be the same."
couldnt be true.
What you describe here is leave the top 16 bits the same and only add artificial bits from dithering,processing in the lower 8 bit from a 24 bit word.
Sorry George, but that is complete unlogical for me as the signal then have on the top 16 coarse steps(the original 16bit from full signal to zero) and then you will add 8 bits more BELOW (the original 16bit) zero ?
George is correct.
Resolution enhancement can be added in two ways;
1, Pad the least significant bits (LSB) with zeros (this is what SPDIF looks like anyway because it's always 24 bits)
2, Use DSP to re interpolate the LSBs, effectively smoothing the steps between them. (16 to 24 bit will add 256 extra steps)
Reducing the signal by 6dB is equivalent to reducing the word length by 1bit, BUT the reality is that the signal is still 24 bits and any further DSP is done with 24 bits of accuracy (or more depending on the DSP engine)
The problem here is trying to understand digital signals, bits and dBs. You can't take away 0.5 bits, but you can take away 0.5dB.
My thinking is that the +3dB and -3dB settings allow the original signal to be bit perfect in the MSB due to the -3dB processor offset, in effect making the signal 0dB or -6dB and -6dB is very easy maths, the whole word can be shifted 1bit towards the LSB.
For signals up to 23bits, no actual information would be lost, for 16bits there will be no loss at all.
Steve.
Sorry Steve,
to point 1)
an ENHANCEMENT makes things better.
So just filling zeros in the lower bits doesnt ENHANCE something,
its just filling up bits.
And you cannot do anything with that signal when you leave that unchanged.
The usage of a digital to analog conversion is to have instead of a digitalnumber or information(in bits) a voltage that correspond to the number the value of the digital information.
So the highest possible number is full voltage, and the lowest possible number(0) is the lowest voltage (0 voltage)
The MSB is the highest bit, the LSB the lowest bit.
To get the maximum output the MSB and ALL other have to be set-this is the highest number.
To get the minimum output all bits have NOT to be set-this is the lowest number.
So every digital number between that two extremes,
means a certain amplitude of the signal.
This is correct for booth 16bit and 24bit words, only the step size of the voltage is different as you have more numbers with 24bit as you have with 16bits.
You have to have the same proportion between the digital numbers and the output voltage,
for example a 1/4 or 1/2 or 3/4 of the maximum number in a 16 bit word
have to be a 1/4 or 1/2 or 3/4 of the maximum number of the 24 bit word.
Then everything is correct,you have a linear scale.
So you cant just place the 16bit word in the top bits of a 24bit word and fill out the lower bits.
Then you dont have linearity anymore.
I dont understand the purpose of filling the lower bits.
point2)
Interpolate from 16 bit to 24 bit or scale as I explained in my prevoius post,
is an ENHANCEMENT as it makes more (artifucially) steps.
This is sensefull, as you get smaller increment or smoother analoge voltage out of your A/D converter.
But going from 16bit to 24bit makes not 256 steps more- it makes MUCH more.
16 bits have 65.535 steps
24 bits have 16,777.215 steps.
So you will get not 256 steps more, you will get (16,777.215 minus 65.536) 16,711.680 steps more !!
You cannot add the steps -you have to multiply the steps because the 8bit(=256steps) "and" 8bit(=256steps) are NOT 512 steps.
The correct maths is 256(8bit)steps MULTIPLY with 256(8bit)steps !
And 24 bits are 65536 steps(16bit) multiplied with 256(8bit) means 16,711.680 steps(24bit)
Speaking in Signal-Noise-Ratio SNR ---with 16bits you have 96dBSNR
and with 24bit you get 144dB SNR!!
In a 16bit-word and a 24bit-word you have 6dB signal difference means 1bit.
So shift 6dB makes sense, as you shift exactly one bit as Steve described.
The volume control in the DSP(8k) is done with 48bit.