George,

from your post:

"When you convert 16bit to 24bit you can't just "stretch" 16 bits into 24 or you'd push a bunch of significant resolution down to levels you won't hear.
16 bit and 24 but are on the SAME scale starting from the TOP bits. This is done for compatibility of 16, 20, 24 bit SPDIF. This is why low noise floor is critical to hear any improvement over 16bits. It's all dynamic range added to the botto
m."


Top bits a clear-its a practical reason for your D/A converter.
A digital full signal(all bits are set)have to correspond to a full analog singnal.
That means the output voltage at the D/A converter cant be higher with 24 bits as with 16 bits,
as then the following amplifier get overloaded.
And no bit set means (theoratically ) zero voltage from the D/A converter and zero voltage input to the following amplifier.
This is the minimum output from the D/A converter or the minimum input to the following input-amplifier.

The 16 bits A/D conversion from the record means that you have between the loudest signal is full range(all bits are set) and the zero bit(no bit set) 16bit steps or 65536 single steps.
When you want to convert this to 24bit the top bit is the same(all 24 bits are set) and the zero bit are the same (no of the 24bits are set).
And logically between this two conditions you have now 24 bit-steps or 16777216 single steps.

Thats the correct way to convert 16 bit words to 24bit words.
If you dont make that in that way,you dont have a linear signal
means full is full -half is half- zero is zero.

For example when only the MSB is set(all other are non set) in a 16bit word its the same analog output after the D/A converter as if you only have set the MSB in 24bit word-means half the full signal.
So booth(16 and 24 ) have the same span of the signal (full signal or nothing at all) BUT have different step size, means the 16 bit step is more coarse then a 24 bit step.

BUT booth are linear from zero to full signal !

So your statement:

"When Meridian says Resolution Enhancement (16 to 24bit) their may be now some new data in the low bits (from dithering and processing) but they are still VERY low level bits (most insignificant ones). The top 16 most significant should be more or less be the same."

couldnt be true.

What you describe here is leave the top 16 bits the same and only add artificial bits from dithering,processing in the lower 8 bit from a 24 bit word.
Sorry George, but that is complete unlogical for me as the signal then have on the top 16 coarse steps(the original 16bit from full signal to zero) and then you will add 8 bits more BELOW (the original 16bit) zero ?

Maybe I didnt catch your explaination, what do you mean?


Robert


800v3/218/271/8k.2/5k5s smile /5kC/DSP3200/Reviver/
TT-ELP/Graham Slee Revelation/Trinnov Altitude 32/OPPO 205
__Ayon/HB/Shunyata/Miltzow -- power cables,
__Ayon/Jungson/Miltzow --analog, Miltzow-- digital,
__Vortex/WMA ,