Originally Posted by George Mills
I've been thinking hard about this and I think I might understand what we are dealing with.

<snip>

When you adjust volume digitally you are shifting down the MOST significant bits !! And pushing the least significant ones out (the ones Meridian added and is tossing as you lower volume digitally).

<snip rest of very informative post #115800>

We have come a long way from our initial (jumped to) conclusion: that there might be a bug in the G68 firmware. This conclusion was based on the report that the raise in quality was not gradually with the raise in level, but only worked on exactly +3dB.

With George's new 0.5dB difference test it became clear the effect might be gradually after all. This also means that you might indeed say that digital volume control comes at a cost (which George suggested earlier).

Your above post explores that further to explain where the cost factor lies: with the DAC. It got me thinking, and maybe the following might explain it a bit more. Most current DAC's are the delta/sigma type: this is a sort cross between 1-bit and multi-bit. Mostly they are around 4 to 6 bits and use oversampling to compensate for the lack of resolution (like SACD uses 64 times oversampling for its 1 bit scheme). So if you lower your volume with 1 bit (6dB), you actually reduce the resolution of the DAC to only 3 to 5 bits. It is clear that the effect of digital volume can heavily depend on the DAC used in the system. For instance there may also be a big difference between Mk1 DSP speakers (5K, 5K5 and 6K) and Mk2 and current DSP speakers. Did anybody try the +3dB mod with Mk1 DSP speakers? It's just a thought.