Originally Posted by dr.bill
It's funny how some of us hear certain things while others don't seem to. To me the 621 presented a small but clear difference: I felt like I was more inside the soundstage and it was somewhat cleaner sound. Pardon the inadequate words. With the +3db tweak I felt some of the same improvements but there was, to my ears, a small cost: the sound appeared brighter and of course I'm factoring in the volume difference. It's very difficult to gauge these things and ultimately you get used to the differences and the newer settings until you toggle back and even then... Perhaps a longer timeframe for the 3db tweak and more A/B by several "testers" will shed more light on this, or not. Also, if there is any truth to the age of ears and the younger the more frequencies heard, then this further clouds the tests and tweaks; but then again Bob Stuart's et al ears are not exactly 18 and appreciating the fuller spectrum. Is a "tester" in their 50s or even 60s as reliable as one in their 20s and 30s? Do we trust anyone over 30? Is this post hoodinism or some such term I've never heard?

Maybe because we are comparing an Airport Express/AppleTV vs a Transporter and HD621 may help more on one vs the other due to jitter? It is interesting the only other person I know with a Transporter and HD621 doesn't hear what the HD621 adds either.

Also I don't think the averge nut on this forum goes to as trouble as I do setting up D2 (etc.) so that I can do direct instant compares. And are depending on memory. When I first plugged the HD621 in I could swear it was better until I did some serious A/B comparisons. I understand that is dangerous and the brain can trick you. But it's dangerous depending on memory too. It's certainly in the realm of very small. How many folks even tried hooking up their HD621 direct to DSP speakers compared to a another source connected directly to take other components (like G68) out of the equation (which so happened to be significantly influencing what you hear)?

It's also consistent with folks toggling HS=Y/N on the processor into DSP speakers that have Apodizing and I think the general consensus was it wasn't much. But we have gernerally written that off as what Apodizing is in DSP speakers is not as good as HD621 or "too late" in the chain.

It's also consistent with what Meridian more or less is saying, don't go out of your way to route audio through your HD621.

Don't get me wrong HD621 is a nice piece of kit and does it's job. But I think the apodizing thing was a bit over hyped. At least that's what I'm finding.

Now back to the +3dB discussion please.


- Fiddler (IMHO)

If you think listening to music is fun, try learning an instrument.
HT: G61RSL, 4x5K, 5.5KHC, 2xSC6000, Transporter, HD621, Philips BDP7501 4K, Tivo, 65" LG OLED 4K C6
Computer: Foobar2000, 5K, Mojo, HiFiMan HE1000 V2