I've been thinking hard about this and I think I might understand what we are dealing with.

When you convert 16bit to 24bit you can't just "stretch" 16 bits into 24 or you'd push a bunch of significant resolution down to levels you won't hear.

16 bit and 24 but are on the SAME scale starting from the TOP bits. This is done for compatibility of 16, 20, 24 bit SPDIF. This is why low noise floor is critical to hear any improvement over 16bits. It's all dynamic range added to the bottom.

On the SqueezeBox and Transporter it has 24bit bit volume control but when you set it to "Max" it just uses the top 16bits. That's why DTS can still pass through. In other words the 16bits you started with are the MOST significant ones in 24 bit. Makes me also wonder if SqueezeBox properly flags it 16bit (when set to Max) and Meridian reads it as 16bits and not 24 (more testing some day).

When Meridian says Resolution Enhancement (16 to 24bit) their may be now some new data in the low bits (from dithering and processing) but they are still VERY low level bits (most insignificant ones). The top 16 most significant should be more or less be the same.

When you adjust volume digitally you are shifting down the MOST significant bits !! And pushing the least significant ones out (the ones Meridian added and is tossing as you lower volume digitally).

So I don't think it matters if it's been resolution enhanced or not. It's still effectively 16bits that your listening to !!

So I still think you are losing .5 bits out of (roughly) 16 bits (most significant ones) at 0dB offset and 1 full bit if you were at -3dB. I was at -3dB and now I'm at +3dB (I went from 15 bits to 16 bits).

This is why the test I did (a few posts back) makes sense.

I was comparing 15.83bits vs 16bits (hard to hear even instantly). That's not quite right but it isn't 23.83bits vs 24bits (which is what we are thinking).

But my original "Tweak", for me, was 15 vs 16bits (easy to hear even if not instant).

I abandoned this post at first, thinking, no, the DSP Speaker would slide the bits back up into the same position and you should hear no difference. That would be true if the DSP speaker implemented digital volume. But it does not. It does it in analog (and we want it to be analog). Meridian does some magic their with digital too (i.e. Hybrid) but for discussion purposes we should treat it as analog because it performs as well as analog and it is trying to maintain full resolution. The DSP speaker should effectively raise the volume in analog into the same human hearing range.

But DACs and ADCs are not perfect. They have a technical format width they can accept (16bit, 24bit etc.) and an effective performance (more like 12 bit`s for 16bit DAC and more like 18 bits for a 24bit DAC). Don`t want to argue that, but it`s less than the word spec size, they are not perfect. We have oscilloscopes with 8bit ADC`s that cost $23,000.00 and their effective performance is 5.5 bits !!! DACs are not perfectly linear either.

So the point is we don`t really receive 24 bits to our ears and what is super important is the most significant bits are more important than least (that`s why they are least significant). If we push things down by .5 or 1 bit, We`ve lost .5 or 1 bit of the best performing part of the DAC (the top).

So I`m back to my same conclusion that the offset should be applied in analog section of the DSP speaker.

In other words digital attentuation is not ok because it's 24-bit word size. You have to put into the context of effective DAC performance (which is less than 24-bits).

Let's say you pay $10K for an effective 20-bit DAC. And you pay $20K for an effective 21-Bit DAC. And you hear that improvement. Both DACs ACCEPT 24bit word size. Now you shift the data down 1 bit. Your $20K DAC just became a $10K DAC.

So Meridian is right 0dB offset is the ideal (as software allows). But it's really +3dB.


- Fiddler (IMHO)

If you think listening to music is fun, try learning an instrument.
HT: G61RSL, 4x5K, 5.5KHC, 2xSC6000, Transporter, HD621, Philips BDP7501 4K, Tivo, 65" LG OLED 4K C6
Computer: Foobar2000, 5K, Mojo, HiFiMan HE1000 V2