Hi George,
I haven't had time yet.
However, let me ask the following....(and don't shout at me I am just being devil's advocate to ensure we are clear). I have been dwelling on this for a few days now.
Are you suggesting:-
That the 3dB digital adjustment downwards that you believe M to make in the processor is actually impacting the bits/resolution of the final playback and that is the extra detail in what you hear?
That the improved detail you hear is not due simply to the increase in playback level and psycho-acoustics?
That this impact on quality and detail (not volume level) of removing the 3dB reduction in the processor is of a greater relative scale (i.e. more noticeable) than any impact that apodizing brings via the HD621 ?
cheers
N
My (brain) my (ears) believes this is way more than HD621 "adds".
I'm am one of the most cautious folks being careful about psycho-acoustics effects.
I don't hear AXIS changes.
I don't hear upsampling in G68 (or 861).
I don't hear differences in G68 and 861).
I don't hear cable differences.
I don't hear power conditioner differences.
I don't hear HD621 adding anything to CD playpack.
I do hear a difference increased quality (not loudness) making this (fronts at 0x26) change (confirmed by two brave folks so far).
I do hear a difference tilting DSP-6000 heads (confirmed by others).
I did hear a difference wiring Transporter Direct and G68 running Direct Preset (but not any more)
But I want others to confirm.
I will try to measure Rears above +3db for digital clipping soon. I suspect with full scale they may clip. But 99% of material to rears is not Full Scale. Meridian themselves allows up to +10dB boost in rears in the DSP presets (even discrete presets like cinema). I'm 99.999% sure nothing will clip at +3dB because Processor immediately subtracts 3dB for some headroom and you end up at 0dB (Full Scale straight through on any channel set to 0x26, I've confirmed this with a meter but not but looking at the digital wave forms). I believe Fronts(set at 0x26) will be perfect Full Scale in to Full Scale out. But rears will clip (with full scale test signal) by 2dB with mine set at +5.0db. But in practice I don't think this is issue (it's not gonna crackle or snap unless it was severe clipping). And it's rare for for full scale to be sent to rears.
I probably will not test all combinations of bass routing. If Meridian goes "above" 0dB due to bass routing I don't think 3dB would be enough.
Why it's just 3dB is actually what's puzzling. 10dB would make more sense.
Only reason 3dB makes sense is to allow center (DSP Preset) to be boosted by 3dB. If that is the only reason it makes sense.
In effect if I set my rears in the DSP Preset to +5.0dB and my calibration on rears to 0dB (legal) I should get the same clipping in rears as DSP Preset set to 0.0db and Calibration set to +5.0db (illegal in the UI).
If I wanted to be "safer" I could set all channels to 0x26 (+3.0dB which I believe will never clip) and change all my DSP Presets to +2.0dB in the rears only. It would be the same as what I have now.