Dolf,

I suppose you should add me to the Lossy camp for portable audio files.

My digital audio workflow is similar to that of others:

CD -> EAC -> FLAC -> lame -> MP3

I keep a lossless master/archive copy of all of my music I rip to my server and it is these FLAC files that I stream in-house to my Logitech/Slimdevices boxes (SliMP3, Squeezebox 3 and Duet).

I then create a high quality, lossy MP3 copy of all files for use on my and my wife's portable audio devices (two iPod nano's and my Blackberry Storm).

When I first ventured into ripping CD's and MP3 encoding, I used my 596 to compare the original CD to the MP3 (encoded with lame, VBR, target bitrate of ~256kbs) and found that I was extremely hard pressed to hear a difference. At the time, my playback chain was 596->568.1->558->B&W Matrix 804 speakers.

This experimentation convinced me to not overly worry about using lossy MP3 encoding.

My home NAS is now significantly larger and my playback chain is entirely digital, so I made the decision to rerip my entire library and store it in FLAC for home use.

However, for portable audio, I see no benefit to going beyond my high quality MP3's. Between the limitations of the D->A stages of portable devices, use of earbud type headphones and ambient noise levels, I just don't believe there would be any audible improvement in carrying around FLAC vs. MP3 on my devices.

Heck, even at home in my office, listening on a nice headphone setup with Sennheiser HD600's and a HeadRoom Total Bithead amp/DAC, I cannot discern any significant difference between FLAC and MP3.

Dan


Last edited by Dan W; 2009-09-17 05:38. Reason: changed lossless to lossy in first statement

Current: Anthem MRX300, B&W Matrix 804 Front L/R, B&W Matrix HTM Center, B&W Matrix 805 Surround L/R, PS3, Squeezebox v3, Popcorn Hour A100

Retired: 568.1, 562v2, 596, 558, DSP5000 Mk1 24/96, DSP5000C Mk1 24/96