Having now seen Gladiator on Bluray, I feel that it is necessary to call out the Studios on the poor quality of this release.

Edge Enhancement and Digital Noise Reduction are everywhere to be seen on the Theatrical Release movie sections (which come from a 2001 master) and they are nowhere to be seen on the Extended Cut scenes, which come from a different 2005 master.

Is it better than any previous DVD release?? Of course it is. But is that the only criteria by which we should judge a Milestone release such as this?? Not IMHO. Every Bluray release should take FULL advantage of the medium, resolution and bit-rates that are offered, and not just meet some minimum criteria. If we want all future Bluray releases to fully exploit the potential of Bluray, then the Studios should be called out and exposed. It's quite obvious that they were just trying to save a buck and they should just have prepared another master, using the Tools available in 2009.

It should be remembered that this release is part of the so-called Sapphire Series, allegedly offering the best in AV Quality. It patently fails in this regard. Braveheart also forms part of this new series and a comparison of the two readily shows up how much they got right with the Braveheart release and how they got it wrong with Gladiator.

It should also be noted that the EE and DNR issues (amongst others) with Gladiator are EASILY seen on a 50" Plasma and even more easily seen on a Projection Screen. No slow motion or frame by frame advance is required. A simple normal speed Play is all that's required

Allowing the Movie Studios to get away with Sub-Standard Quality Releases doesn't do any of us any good, especially when the movie is a "seminal" release like this one. It will merely encourage them to continue to try and skimp in the future with other releases. Raising our collective voices will make it clear that we cannot be treated like sheep and fed the lowest common denominator.

Last edited by Ronnie Hurley; 2009-09-15 09:21.

-