Well, I've watched the extended cut and...
- I don't think the extra scenes actually add anything to the film. Ridley Scott almost says this in his brief introduction.
- The PQ is pretty good. I really can't see what all the screaming is about. It's better than the SD DVD and you don't notice all the alleged problems. (Note: I do not watch with a magnifying glass 2 inches from the screen or frame-by-frame)
- The big improvement is the soundtrack. This is much better than the SD DVD version, particularly the music presentation.
So, not nearly as problematical as has been suggested. �15 well spent - yes.